I Thought He Had a Secret Child. The Truth Was Worse.
A School Reunion, A Whispered Secret, and a Marriage on the Edge.
Story: S A Spencer
Author of Popular Fictions: The Pink Mutiny, The Black Waters, Dream In Shackles
Have you ever made a
life-altering decision based on a misunderstanding? I did. And it cost me my
marriage.
I’m Chloe Bennett, a
schoolteacher from Sydney. I was married to Ethan Bennett for 21 years. He’s a
successful businessman, charming, generous, and deeply loyal — or so I
believed. What happened at his school reunion in Albury last year changed
everything. Or rather, what I thought happened.
This is not just a story about
betrayal. It’s about assumptions, silence, and the stories we tell ourselves
when we’re afraid to ask the truth.
Ethan and I met through mutual
friends in Sydney. I was recovering from a painful divorce — my first husband
left me when we discovered I couldn’t have children. Ethan was kind, patient,
and never made me feel incomplete. He had his own past: a brief high school
romance in Albury, a small town 500 kilometres away, and a childhood shaped by
loss. His mother died when he was a baby, and he was raised by his father and a
nanny who later became their cook.
Ethan often spoke of his nanny
with reverence. “I may not have met my biological mother,” he’d say, “but my
nanny was like a mother to me.” He sent her money regularly and visited her in
Albury. I never joined him — I always found excuses. Work. Travel. The town
seemed dull. I regret that now.
When she passed away last year,
Ethan was devastated. I felt guilty for never meeting her, never even asking
her name. She could’ve been like a mother-in-law to me. That guilt lingered.
A few months after Ethan’s nanny
passed away, he mentioned that his high school friends were planning another
reunion in Albury. He’d attended these gatherings before — always alone. I’d
never shown interest. But this time, something felt different.
“Are you going again?” I asked
casually over dinner.
He nodded. “Daniel’s organizing
it. Same place, same crowd.”
I hesitated. “Do people usually
bring their partners?”
He shrugged. “Some do. It’s a
co-ed school, so there are couples, old flames, new ones too. But most come
solo. Easier that way.”
“Easier?” I echoed, trying to
mask the sting in my voice.
Ethan looked up from his plate.
“I mean, not everyone’s partner wants to spend a weekend in a sleepy town with
people they’ve never met.”
I smiled, but something inside me
shifted. “I’d like to come this time.”
He paused. “Really?”
“Yes. I think it’s time I met
your old friends.”
His expression was unreadable —
not quite pleased, not quite resistant. “Of course. You’re welcome.”
That night, while Ethan worked
late, I found myself scrolling through his Facebook. We weren’t connected —
something I hadn’t noticed before. His profile was sparse, but tagged photos
from past reunions revealed something curious: a woman who appeared beside him
in nearly every picture.
Sophia Turner.
She was striking — confident,
elegant, and always smiling. In one photo, Ethan had his arm around her
shoulders. In another, they were laughing, heads tilted close. I zoomed in,
searching for clues. Was she the high school girlfriend he’d mentioned? He’d
never told me her name. Just that it was a brief relationship, nothing serious.
But these photos told a different
story. They looked comfortable. Familiar. Like two people who shared more than
just memories.
I clicked through Sophia’s
profile. She wasn’t married — at least not publicly. Her posts were tasteful,
guarded. No mention of a partner. No children. Just travel, books, and
occasional throwbacks to school days in Albury.
My stomach tightened.
Was their old flame rekindling?
Had Ethan been seeing her during his solo trips to Albury? Was the nanny story
a convenient cover?
I didn’t want to believe it. But
the seed of doubt had been planted.
I told myself I was being
paranoid. That Ethan was loyal. That Sophia was just a friend. But the photos
lingered in my mind. The way he smiled with her. The way she leaned into him.
I needed to see for myself.
We reached Albury just after
midday. The town hadn’t changed much — quiet streets, familiar eucalyptus trees
lining the roads, and that peculiar stillness only small towns seem to hold.
Ethan’s classmate Daniel greeted us warmly. He’d offered us a guest room in his
home, and while Ethan chatted with him like old times, I felt like an outsider
peering into a world I didn’t belong to.
Daniel was charming, but guarded.
Over tea, he spoke about classmates who had rekindled old flames, some now
living together after divorces. “Funny how time bends things back into place,”
he said, glancing at Ethan. I smiled politely, but my mind was racing. He
hadn’t mentioned Sophia. Was that deliberate?
Later, while Ethan and Daniel
reminisced in the backyard, I wandered through the house. On a shelf in the
hallway, I spotted a framed photo — a group shot from a previous reunion. Ethan
stood in the center, arm around a woman I didn’t recognize. It wasn’t Sophia.
She had auburn hair, a confident smile, and her hand rested lightly on Ethan’s
chest. I turned the frame over. No names. No date.
“Who’s this?” I asked Daniel
casually when he returned.
“Oh, that’s Ava Mitchell. She was
in our year. Lives nearby. She’s had a rough few years, poor thing.”
I nodded, filing the name away.
Ava. Not Sophia. But why had I assumed Sophia was the one always beside Ethan
in the reunion photos? Had I misidentified her?
That evening, Ethan and I went
for a walk. The streets were quiet, the air crisp. I asked, “Do you ever feel
like coming back here?”
He smiled. “Sometimes. But
Sydney’s home now.”
“Do you still talk to your old
girlfriend?”
He paused. “Not really. She moved
overseas years ago.”
“Was her name Sophia?”
He looked surprised. “No. Why?”
I shrugged. “Just curious.”
He didn’t press further. But I
did.
Back at Daniel’s house, I
scrolled through the reunion photos again. The woman beside Ethan — the one I’d
assumed was Sophia — was Ava. And Ava was still in Albury.
The next morning, we arrived at
the school for the reunion. Ethan was immediately swept into conversations,
laughter, handshakes. I stood back, observing. He hadn’t introduced me to
anyone. I took the initiative, greeting wives and female alumni. One woman
blinked when I said I was Ethan’s wife. “Oh, I thought he was divorced,” she
said, then quickly changed the subject.
Another whispered to her friend,
“She’s here. I didn’t think she’d come.”
Was I intruding on something?
Then I saw her — Sophia. She
arrived late, alone, and seemed to avoid Ethan. I approached her. “Hi, I’m
Chloe, Ethan’s wife.”
She blinked. “Oh, you’re here
with him?” Her tone was neutral, but her eyes flickered with something —
surprise? Discomfort?
I turned away, heart pounding.
Something wasn’t right.
Then, behind me, I overheard a
conversation.
“He’s the father of your child,
and he’s right here. You’re too easy on him. Ask him to help with his studies.
So what if your son is 18? He still needs money.”
I didn’t look back. But I was
certain they were talking about Sophia. Or was it Ava?
The woman beside Ethan in the
photos. The one Daniel said had a rough few years. The one who lived nearby.
Had I mistaken Ava for Sophia all
along?
Ethan and I left Albury that
afternoon. I was silent during the drive. He asked, “Chloe, what’s wrong?”
“Just a headache,” I said. But
the ache was deeper. I had seen enough — or so I thought.
I didn’t confront Ethan. I didn’t
ask questions. I filed for a no-fault divorce and left.
I wouldn’t have minded if he’d
told me the truth — that he had a son with his ex and was supporting him. But
the nanny story felt like a cover-up. I felt deceived. Betrayed. My second
marriage collapsed under the weight of silence and suspicion.
I moved back to my mother’s
ancestral home. My sister, still single, welcomed me. My mother, who never
remarried after my father abandoned us, understood my pain. She spoke of single
mothers struggling without support. She mentioned Sophia and her son, now 18,
still needing help for his education.
I decided to visit Sophia in
Albury. I messaged her on Facebook: “Hi, I’m Chloe. We met at the reunion. Can
we talk?”
She replied instantly with her
address.
Sophia welcomed me warmly. I told
her Ethan and I had separated. She was surprised. “I didn’t know. Ethan isn’t
active online. I’m sorry to hear that.”
I said, “He only told me half the
truth. I wouldn’t have minded meeting my stepson.”
Sophia looked confused. “Ethan
has a son?”
“No,” I clarified. “I mean your
son. Ethan is his father. He stopped supporting him when he turned 18. I want
to help.”
Sophia blinked. “I don’t have a
son. I’m happily married — to this wonderful woman beside me.”
Her partner entered the room,
smiling. “Wait, Sophia, you had a son with Ethan?”
Sophia laughed. “No! Ethan was
just a classmate. His ex-girlfriend moved abroad years ago. I never dated him.
You must’ve overheard someone else at the reunion.”
I was stunned. The woman I’d seen
with Ethan in the photos wasn’t Sophia. The conversation I’d overheard wasn’t
about her. I’d built an entire narrative on a mistaken identity.
Later, I learned the woman with
Ethan in the photos was Ava Mitchell — another classmate. She had a son, and
the biological father wasn’t Ethan. The reunion gossip wasn’t about Sophia at
all.
I had left my husband over a
story I’d written in my head.
Back in Sydney, I sat alone in my
apartment, staring at the divorce papers. I hadn’t even asked Ethan for his
side. I’d let fear and pride guide me.
If I’d asked, he might’ve told me
about Ava. He might’ve explained the photos. He might’ve reassured me. But I
didn’t give him the chance.
I learned two things:
1. Never make decisions in anger. They’re
rarely wise.
2. Always ask. Silence breeds stories.
Stories breed regret.
I wrote Ethan a letter. I never
sent it. But I’ll share a part of it here:
“I’m sorry. I should’ve asked. I
should’ve trusted you enough to hear your truth. I let my past shape my fears,
and my fears shape my choices. You deserved better.”
💬 What Do You Think?
Have you ever misjudged someone
based on a fragment of truth? Have you ever let silence speak louder than
words?
I’d love to hear your thoughts.
Leave a comment below — I read every one.
Stay tuned for more stories that
explore the fragile threads of trust, memory, and redemption.
S A Spencer- I will bring more stories for your entertainment. Please follow me on Facebook and Twitter so that you know when a new story comes.
Do you like this story? Let your friends also read this.
Download this thriller -FREE for a limited time
Comments
Post a Comment